Metal vs. Asphalt: What’s Best for Sheboygan’s Winters?

When winter storms sweep through Sheboygan, your roof takes the brunt. Snow, ice, wind, and freeze-thaw cycles challenge every material. At Moore Quality Exteriors, we've helped homeowners decide between metal and asphalt roofing—and have seen firsthand how each performs under local conditions.

Metal Roofs: Built for Wisconsin’s Weather

Metal roofing is known for its durability and longevity, often lasting 40 to 70 years. One of its greatest advantages in Wisconsin is how effectively it sheds snow and ice, reducing the risk of ice dams that plague many homes each winter. Metal also stands up well to high winds and hail, making it an excellent choice for storm resistance.

In addition, metal roofs are energy-efficient and recyclable, offering eco-friendly benefits many homeowners now value.

That said, metal roofs come with a higher upfront cost—often two to three times more than asphalt shingles. Without snow guards, the slick surface can also create sudden snow slides, which may be dangerous near walkways. And while many homeowners appreciate the modern look, others find them noisier during rain or hail, though proper insulation usually resolves that issue.

Asphalt Shingles: A Cost-Conscious Option

Asphalt shingles remain the most common roofing choice in Wisconsin for good reason. They are significantly more affordable upfront, widely available, and offer a broad range of colors and styles to suit almost any home. Asphalt shingles are also quieter during storms, something homeowners with bedrooms near the roofline may appreciate.

The downside is lifespan. Even high-quality asphalt shingles generally last 15 to 30 years—much shorter than metal. In climates like Sheboygan’s, with repeated freeze-thaw cycles, asphalt roofs are more prone to ice dams, shingle damage, and general wear over time. Asphalt is also less environmentally friendly, since it’s petroleum-based and difficult to recycle.

Real Sheboygan Case Studies

Case 1 — Coastal Home Re-Roofed with Metal
A home near Lake Michigan struggled with recurring ice dam issues. We installed standing seam metal roofing in early fall. The smooth surface allowed snow to slide off cleanly, eliminating the leaks the homeowner had battled for years.

Case 2 — Neighborhood Asphalt Re-Shingle
In another project, a traditional Sheboygan neighborhood home received new architectural asphalt shingles. While the lifespan won’t match metal, the upgraded shingles provided excellent durability and blended beautifully with neighboring homes. The lower price point also made the choice more practical for the homeowner’s budget.

Making the Right Choice for Your Home

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer when it comes to roofing. For homeowners who plan to stay in their homes long term and want maximum winter protection, metal roofing offers superior performance. For those balancing cost, style, and neighborhood fit, asphalt shingles remain a dependable option.

At Moore Quality Exteriors, our goal is to help you make the best decision for your home—not just for today, but for decades to come.

Contact us today for a free roof consultation and let’s find the right solution for your Sheboygan home.